|
Product |
S/W |
Setup |
Scanning |
Import |
Licensing |
Platforms |
Database |
Client |
HIPAA |
Workflow |
COLD |
Email |
Our Likes |
Our Dislikes |
|
Simple
Software
SimpleIndex
with
SimpleSearch |
$-$$ |
$-$$ |
TWAIN & ISIS scanning with robust automated indexing |
A variety of ways exist to utilize exiting information from CSV
index files, databases or folder/filenames . |
Per workstation; scanning & OCR features optional |
Windows 2000/XP/2003/Vista |
Any ODBC or OleDB supported database |
Desktop only |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Low cost and simple design make it a great solution for desktop
or small office solutions. |
Not scalable for large numbers of users; limited search and
viewing options; limited security options. |
|
Digitech
Systems
PaperVision Xpress |
$-$$$ |
$-$$ |
Not included; use
SimpleIndex or
PaperFlow |
Must use PaperVision Datagroup format;
only
SimpleIndex
and
PaperFlow support. |
Per named workstation |
Windows 2000/XP/2003 |
SQL Server Xpress 2005 (included) |
Desktop only |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Scaled-down and simplified version of
PaperVision Enterprise is easy to setup and offers a very good,
stable searching and viewing interface. |
Named client licensing makes Xpress
more expensive than Enterprise when several users need
infrequent access to documents. |
|
Digitech
Systems
PaperVision Enterprise |
$-$$$$ |
$-$$$$ |
Not included; use
SimpleIndex
or
PaperFlow |
Directory Manager automatically imports
network files using folders/filenames for indexing; PaperVision
Datagroups also supported. |
Per concurrent server connection; License includes all DB,
server & webserver components. |
Windows 2000/XP/2003 (Server OS recommended but not required) |
SQL Server Xpress 2005 (included); SQL Server 2000/2005
supported |
Desktop or Web (includes both) |
Yes |
Yes
(Add-on) |
Yes
(Add-On) |
Yes
(Add-On) |
Includes everything you need with a single license; no
extra server, webserver or database licenses. Simple
setup and user interface and a full range of document management
options. |
No folder-based browsing of documents; Discount structure makes 10-20
user systems more expensive than ViewWise. |
|
CompuThink ViewWise |
$$$-$$$$ |
$$-$$$$ |
Basic TWAIN scanning with manual indexing;
optional ISIS scanning;
SimpleIndex |
Manually import batches of docs in CSV
format; Custom BIF format required for automatic import
(SimpleIndex
supports the BIF format). |
Named and concurrent clients available;
Server, DB, webserver & administration components are extra. |
Windows 2000/2003 Server, Novell Netware
6.5 Server, RedHat Linux, SuSe Linux |
SQL Server 2000/2005; Oracle 9i/10g |
Desktop or Web (licensed separately) |
Yes |
Yes
(Add-On) |
No |
Yes
(Add-On) |
Novell and Linux server and Oracle
database support make this a great choice for companies with
these infrastructures. Folder-style browsing interface
is more intuitive for many. MS Office integration lets you
save files to ViewWise. |
Setup is more complicated than Digitech,
though well-documented; database and web server licenses not
included; no Workflow option. |
|
Ricoh DocumentMall |
$$$-$$$$ |
$-$$$ |
Not included; use
Goby Capture |
Import via automatic uploading application, direct interface with
Ricoh MFPs, faxes. |
Site license based on gigabytes of stored data; Up to 400 users
may access files. |
N/A -
Hosted solution |
N/A - Hosted solution |
Web only |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
Hosted solution means no server to buy & maintain, no
technical staff to hire and other advantages of outsourcing.
Powerful Documentum-based server provides many features. |
Per-gigabyte pricing is expensive and means you will likely
limit the use of the system to only the most important files,
which can hinder adoption of the system by users. |
|
DocuLex
WebSearch |
$-$$ |
$-$$ |
Not included; use
SimpleIndex
or
PaperFlow |
Automatically indexes all images and network content
using folders, filenames, meta tags and text (similar to Google
Desktop) |
Site license - any number of users may use
WebSearch; Small Office version limited to 10 users; Desktop
version available for single users. |
Windows 2000/XP/2003 (Server OS
recommended but not required) |
MSDE SQL Server (Included) |
Web only |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
Site licensing makes this the lowest cost
solution for 10 or more users. Search engine style indexing
model makes getting document into the system very easy. Web
interface can be used on any platform. |
Limited keyword indexing & searching
capabilities--relies on meta tags & full text; No advanced
document management capabilities. |
Windows Folders
& Filenames |
Free |
$ |
Not included; use
SimpleIndex
or
PaperFlow |
Images must be
saved with organized folders and filenames by the scanning
application. Searchable text optional. |
Free with your
copy of Windows |
Network file
shares are truly cross-platform; stored files may be accessed by
any OS. |
Google Desktop or
MS search can be used for fast searching |
Windows Explorer |
No |
No |
No |
No |
With any
batch scanning application you have the ability to simply
use network folders to organize the files. This is a perfectly
legitimate option for many applications and is certainly the
only free one! |
No ability to
share full-text search index with other users with desktop
search applications; no Boolean keyword searches; not compliant
with HIPAA and other regulations. |
|
Product |
S/W |
Setup |
Scanning |
Import |
Licensing |
Platforms |
Database |
Client |
HIPAA |
Workflow |
COLD |
Email |
Our Likes |
Our Dislikes |